Scones (blueberry lemon, cranberry orange, apple cheddar, apricot white chocolate, dark chocolate cherry, lemon currant, chocolate pumpkin, Pineapple Coconut and Butterscotch Maple Pecan) ... $3.25
Muffins (coconut pineapple, morning glory, lemon blueberry, cranberry orange, banana chocolate chip, Rhubarb Almond, Mixed Berry, Peach Streusel) ... $2.75
Cinnamon Buns (always the classic but sometimes we add blueberries or raisins or pecans or apples...) ... $3.25
The Chocolate Sandwich Cookie (the homemade “you know what”) yummy vanilla buttercream sandwiched between two large chocolate cookies ... $3.00
The Peanut Butter Sandwich two big soft peanut butter cookies with a creamy peanut butter filling... for serious peanut butter lovers ... $3.00
Chocolate White Chocolate Chunk dark chocolate cookie with large white chocolate chunks ... $2.00
Oatmeal Cranberry White Chocolate Pecan Loads of oatmeal and raisins in this chewy version of a classic ... $2.00
Milk Chocolate Chip just the basics in this one ... $2.00
Nutty Chocolate Chip tons of roasted walnuts and pecans with bittersweet chocolate ... $2.00
Big Soft Sugar Cookie need we say more? ... $2.00
Gingersnaps big and chewy with just the right balance of molasses and spices ... $2.00
Snickerdoodle A simple sugar cookie rolled in cinnamon sugar ... $2.00
Empire Cookie Two sugar cookies sandwiched between raspberry jam and topped with almond icing ... $3.00
Nutella or Pistachio Macaroons with dark chocolate bottoms ... $3.00
Red Velvet Whoopie Pies On offer every Saturday! ... $3.25
Pumpkin Whoopie Pies Only on offer from September through January so get em' while you can ... $3.25
The Hello Dolly a classic from the 60's (if it ain't broke don't fix it!) Graham crust with condensed milk, chocolate, pecans and coconut ... $3.00
The Dunbar Our most popular bar...an oatmeal base with loads of chocolate, pecans, coconut and dulce du lece ( mexican caramel) in the middle ... $3.00
Brownie Our version is fudgy with lots of walnuts ... $3.00
Lemon Bar Lots of lemon with some coconut and walnuts make this pretty special ... $3.00
Pecan Bar Shortbread base with lots of gooey caramel and pecans ... $3.00
The Peanut Butter Ball for serious peanut butter fans...one bite and you are hooked! ... $1.75
Nanaimo Bar We know you aren’t from around these parts if you don’t know this one ... $3.00
Dream Bar The bestselling bar in the bakery! Shortbread crust, cherries, walnuts and coconut topped with vanilla butter cream ... $3.00
Peanut Butter Marshmallow Slice We used to only sell this one during the Christmas season but our customers demanded it year round ... $1.75
Vunderbar As much fun to eat as it is to say. Chocolate, peanut butter, rice krispies and oats topped with a little more chocolate! ... $1.75
Butterscotch Krispy Bar Rice krispies, butterscotch and a little chocolate on top ... $1.75
Chocolate Cherry Bar This bar is loaded with cherries, coconut, pecans, chocolate and just a touch of coffee ... $3.00
Smartie Pants Bar Our perfect chocolate brownie sprinkled with a generous helping of Smarties ... $3.00
Coney Island Bar A deep fudgey base topped with more chocolate and walnuts and then finished with our own Toasted Coconut Marshmallows ... $3.00
Bajillionaire Bar ….Brown sugar shortbread crust, creamy caramel centre finished with dark chocolate and a sprinkling of sea salt ... $3.00
Campfire Bar The best part of any camping trip without leaving home. Graham crumb crust, chocolate and our own vanilla marshmallow on top ... $3.00
Chocolate Coconut Brownie Chocolate and Coconut is a match made in heaven ... $3.00
The selection varies every day so give us a call to check what is in the cooler or preorder your favorites... Chocolate with chocolate buttercream • Pumpkin Maple • Red Velvet • Coconut • Lemon Mocha • Maple walnut • Chocolate peanut butter • Chocolate Rasberry (to die for!) • Chocolate Mint • Chocolate Pistachio • Nutella High Tops • Peanut Butter and Jelly ... $3.00 each and mini cupcakes are sold by the dozen for $18
Chocolate Chocolate A three layer moist chocolate cake smothered in chocolate butter cream with just a few sprinkles on the top ... 7" $35 ... 9" $45
Vanilla Cake with Buttercream icing A three layer vanilla cake with any colour butter cream you like! ... 7" $35 ... 9" $45
Lemon Cake A three layer vanilla cake with loads of lemon butter cream ... 7" $35 ... 9" $45
Coconut Cake three layers of vanilla cake with piles of cream cheese butter cream ... 7" $38 ... 9" $48
Carrot Cake the nine inch version of this cake weighs in at 7 and a half pounds! Thats a lot of carrots, pineapple,walnuts and creamcheese icing! ... 7" $38 ... 9" $48
The Black Bird a chocolate cake for a true chocolate lover... very dense with a little brandy and lots of coffee finished with a chocolate ganache and a stenciled black bird on top... a truly elegant cake ... 7" $38 ... 9" $48
Chocolate Peanut Butter Our same moist chocolate cake but this time covered in a fluffy peanut butter icing and finished with chocolate sprinkles ... 7" $35 ... 9" $45
Chocolate Pistachio Cake our moist chocolate cake smothered in pistachio butter cream and finished with crushed pistachios ... 7” $38 ... 9” $48
Chocolate Raspberry Cake One of the more popular cakes at the bakery. This chocolate cake is layered and finished with our Raspberry Butter Cream ... 7” $35 ... 9” $45
Butter now offers full and half sheet cakes for feeding a larger crowd.
Full Sheet (approximately 96 slices) ... $210
Half Sheet (approximately 48 slices) ... $145
We ask for at least 24 hours notice on custom orders for our 7" and 9" cakes and a minimum of 3 days notice for sheet cakes. Additional charges apply for theme cakes and use of fondant.
Our selection of pies and tarts varies with the season and our mood so give us a call so we can let you know what is coming out of the oven that day. All our pies and tarts are 9" and cost $21.
Pumpkin • Apple • Mixed Berry • Strawberry Rhubarb • Walnut Butterscotch Shoo Fly • Chocolate Chip • Sour Cream Rhubarb • Peach Raspberry • Chocolate Espresso Pecan • Rasberry Custard
Lemon Meringue Tart A Saturday special unless you order one in advance! Our short and sweet tart shell filled with Butter’s own Lemon Curd piled high with a silky meringue ... 9” $25. Or mini tarts for $3.00 each
For those of you who don't feel like a whole pie try one of our mini versions...
Buttertarts ... $2.25
Mini Lemon Meringue Tarts ... $3.00
Mini Pumpkin Tarts ... $2.25
Lemon Loaf with lots of lemon glaze ... $9.00
Pumpkin Streusal Loaf with pecans and brown sugar on top ... $9.00
Chocolate Orange loaf with a orange glaze ... $9.00
Banana Pecan ... $9.00
Banana Chocolate ... $9.00
Nutella Loaf ... $9.00
Orange Olive Oil ... $9.00
Tiger Loaf ... $9.00
Chocolate Pistachio Loaf ... $9.00
Just as it sounds... these are the best marshmallows you will ever taste! Bag of 10 hand cut marshmallows for $7 (strawberry, vanilla, toasted coconut, mint, coffee, raspberry, passion fruit, rose, violet, pumpkin spice, maple, pistachio, chocolate, lemon, matcha tea, peppermint, eggnog and gingerbread)
S’mores - Butter had created the ultimate s’more! Two made from scratch graham crackers smothered with dark chocolate are sandwiched around one of our gourmet marshmallows. We always have the classic but have added a few other flavours to keep you on your toes…Pumpkin Spice, Chocolate Pistachio, Strawberry, Chocolate Mint and Mocha ... $4.75 each
We are also happy to make many of our treats in a miniature version for corporate events or celebrations. Please give us a call at the bakery to discuss options and pricing.
The holiday season brings many additions to the Butter menu so stop by to have a peek. You expect all the classics you enjoyed as a child and few new goodies to start some new traditions.
With the Butter’s little growth spurt we are now able to offer you a place to sit and enjoy a light breakfast and lunch as well as a cup of Butter’s own private label coffee.
As grown up as that may sound we are still a little commitment adverse so call us or check the chalk board to see what we have on offer each day.
Muffin, Scone, Cinny Bun, Yogurt with fruit compote and Butter’s Granola, A Slice of Oat Loaf with Brown Sugar and Berries ( Butter’s answer to a bowl of oatmeal…wait till you try it!), Fruit Salad, Orange Juice and Waffles on Saturday.
Daily Soup and Daily Sandwich Selection (might include Butter’s Meatloaf Sandwich, Egg Salad, Honey and Brie on Walnut Fig Bread, Peanut Butter and Jam, Roast Vegetable Mozza, Turkey with Cranberry Relish, Ham and Swiss...)
Daily Quiche and some delicious side salads depending on what is fresh at the market.